Example 2: Applying the Future Building Design Value Summary for Cooling Systems
Overheating in buildings is a significant concern for human health, especially for vulnerable populations. With hotter summer days, warmer nighttime lows, and lengthening heat waves projected, future cooling loads require careful evaluation. This includes considering whether some form of mechanical cooling will be needed in locations where this was not needed in the past.
Consider the example of a mechanical engineer responsible for designing the Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning (HVAC) system for a low-rise multi-unit residential building in Toronto, ON. Knowing that overheating is becoming a greater concern, the design team first considered reducing passive loads as much as possible before relying on the mechanical system. This would support the use of a smaller cooling system while also increasing occupant comfort, especially in the case of power outages.
Passive load reductions included measures such as using optimal building orientation and form, low solar-heat-gain windows, reduced window-to-wall ratio, shading devices, and specifying a light-colored roofing membrane. To better retain the cooled air within the building’s interior, the team looked to a high-performance enclosure with an effective wall thermal resistance greater than R-22. They are also committed to ensuring improved building air tightness levels.
With the passive gains significantly reduced, the mechanical engineer could specify an appropriately sized heat pump to manage the remaining cooling load.
Referring to the Future Building Design Value Summary on ClimateData.ca for Toronto (City Hall) ON, the engineer locates the historical 2.5% July Dry Bulb and Wet Bulb temperatures as well as the future design values for 2050 and 2100.
Table 3 – Absolute values for Dry and Wet Bulb Temperatures for Toronto (City Hall), ON, from Future Building Design Value Summaries on ClimateData.ca.
Global Warming Level |
2.5% July Dry Bulb (°C) |
2.5% July Wet Bulb (°C) |
Recent Historic |
31 |
23 |
GWL2001:1.5°C / Mid-Century |
33 |
25 |
GWL2001:3.0°C / End-Century |
35 |
26 |
Knowing that cooling plants typically last for 15 to 25 years, the engineer uses the mid-century dry bulb temperature (33°C) to ensure the system can perform adequately until the end of its service life. Using this data, the engineer can use 2050 dry bulb temperature to find the peak cooling load. The rest of the HVAC system is then designed in accordance with the required peak cooling loads.
However, the engineer’s work is not quite done, as not all the elements in the cooling system have the same 15- to 25-year lifespan. The distribution systems will have a lifespan that exceeds the heat pump: they should be sized to deliver the required amount of chilled air or refrigerant to satisfy the cooling loads for the end of century dry-bulb temperatures. The mechanical rooms should be sized for the potential need for additional cooling equipment, similarly for the placement of additional roof-top curbs if supplemental roof mounted equipment is required. The lesson here is that the cooling load calculations should also be run with the end-of-century value, to ensure that the replacement and/or upgrade systems have already been considered, minimizing future retrofit costs and installation time.